Recruiter Secrets Part 6: Why sizing up other candidates will drive you crazy

Previous launches you may have missed…

Launchpad

• Recruiter Secrets Part 5: The fortune teller problem

• Recruiter Secrets Part 4: Navigating legal and discrimination landmines

Final Draft Resumes Career Advice

• How to optimize your resume for ATS

Resumatic Blog

• Are online resume builders a scam?

Ever caught yourself wondering how you measure up against other candidates?

Maybe you've drafted that email to the recruiter asking about your competition, only to delete it moments later.

It's a natural impulse, but here's why comparing yourself to other candidates might be doing more harm than good.

We've all been there. You're in the middle of a job search, and the questions start creeping in.

"Did the other candidate have more experience?"

"What if they interviewed better?"

"Do they have better qualifications?"

These thoughts aren't just common – they're almost universal among job seekers.

But they're also incredibly unproductive.

Why Recruiters Can't (and Won't) Tell You

Here's the thing: recruiters aren't being difficult when they dodge these questions.

They're bound by confidentiality agreements and professional ethics to keep information about other candidates private.

Think about it – would you want your qualifications and interview performance shared with other candidates?

Probably not.

The Mental Toll of Comparison

When you're focused on other candidates, you're splitting your mental energy between two things: your own performance and imaginary competition.

And let's be honest – that imaginary competition is usually much more intimidating than reality.

You're essentially competing against a perfect version of someone who doesn't exist.

This is what we call the "compare and despair" spiral.

It's exhausting, demoralizing, and completely unnecessary.

What Actually Matters in Your Job Search

The truth is, hiring isn't always about finding the "best" candidate on paper.

It's about finding the right fit for the role, the team, and the company culture.

Your unique combination of skills, experiences, and perspectives might be exactly what the company needs.

But you won't be able to showcase that if you're too busy worrying about other candidates.

Redirecting Your Energy

Instead of asking how you compare to others, try asking questions that actually benefit your candidacy:

"What skills are most crucial for success in this role?"

"Can you tell me more about the team I'd be working with?"

"What challenges would I be expected to tackle in the first six months?"

These questions show recruiters you're focused on the right things – namely, how you can add value to their organization.

Making the Mental Shift

Start thinking of your job search as your own journey, not a competition.

Yes, there are other candidates. Yes, some might have impressive qualifications.

But that has nothing to do with your ability to showcase your value.

Practical Steps Forward

1. Catch yourself when you start comparing. Redirect that energy to preparing for your next interview.

2. Focus on what you can control. Your preparation, your responses, your follow-up – these are all within your power.

3. Ask questions that demonstrate your interest in the role itself, not your standing among other candidates.

4. Keep detailed notes about what you've learned in each interview. Use these insights to improve your next performance.

The Bottom Line

The next time you feel the urge to ask about other candidates, remember this: the only person you're really competing with is yourself.

Your goal isn't to be better than other candidates. It's to be the best version of yourself and the right fit for the role.

That's what recruiters are looking for, and that's where your focus should be.

Besides, wouldn't you rather spend your energy preparing for your next interview than worrying about hypothetical competition?

Focus on your path. Trust the process. And remember – the right opportunity will recognize your value without you having to compare yourself to others.